When We First Met (2018) - Cast

Alexandra Daddario as Avery Martin
Robbie Amell as Ethan
Adam DeVine as Noah Ashby
Noureen DeWulf as Margo
Shelley Hennig as Carrie
Andrew Bachelor as Max
Tony Cavalero as Angus Young
Tenea Intriago as Goth Bride
Chris Wylde as Mr. Costigan
Dean J. West as Phill / Jello Shot Dr.
Martin Bats Bradford as Store Clerk
Ron M Patterson as Halloween party goer
Bryan Michael Hall as Barista
Talbott Lin as Mr. Chun
Michael Scott as Waiter
Kyler Porche as Drunk Idiot
Betsy Medina as Halloween Party Goer
James Kemp as Bartender
Peter Jaymes Jr as .Busboy (as Peter Jaymes)
Adam Henslee as Amos
Karen Dalferes as Mother
John Garcia as Little caesar
Phil Meyer as Jazz Club Patron
Hannah Jacole Powell-Yost as Egg (of Egg & Bacon couple) (as Hannah Powell-Yost)
Daryn Kahn as Drunken Hulk
Bill Rainey as Avery's Dad
Romeraux as Bar Patron
Darrell L. Shuler as Halloween Party Goer (uncredited)